Your Business Has a Buy-Sell Agreement. Does It Still Work?

Your Business Has a Buy-Sell Agreement. Does It Still Work?

Table of Contents

Having a buy-sell agreement is a good start.

But the more important question is whether the agreement still fits the business.

A lot can change after one is signed. The company grows. Its value changes. Owners take on different roles. Insurance stays the same while the business becomes more valuable. New owners join. Someone begins thinking about retirement. The agreement stays in a file.

Then something happens.

An owner dies, becomes disabled, wants out, or proposes a transfer. A relationship deteriorates. The company starts preparing for succession or receives interest from a buyer.

Suddenly, the agreement is no longer theoretical.

The question is not simply whether you have one.

If the agreement had to operate tomorrow, would it produce the result the owners expect today?

Has the Business Changed?

A buy-sell agreement reflects the business as it existed when the agreement was drafted.

Maybe there were two founders, modest revenue, limited assets, and no realistic expectation that anyone would leave for years.

Five or ten years later, the company may look very different.

Its value may have increased substantially. Ownership may have changed. One owner may now run the company while another plays a smaller role. The business may have significant debt, valuable intellectual property, recurring revenue, key employees, or outside financing.

The agreement may still be enforceable and operative.

That does not necessarily mean it still makes business sense.

Major changes in the company are a good reason to take another look.

Would the Valuation Provision Produce a Sensible Number?

The valuation section deserves particular attention because that is where an abstract agreement can become a very real financial obligation.

Some agreements use a fixed value that the owners are expected to update periodically. Others use a formula, appraisal process, or some combination of approaches.

Any of those can work in the right circumstances.

But circumstances change.

A fixed value from years ago may bear little relationship to the current business. A formula designed for a smaller company may produce an odd result after the business becomes substantially more profitable or its economics change.

Even an appraisal procedure can create questions about timing, cost, methodology, or what happens when the parties disagree.

Owners do not need to become valuation experts.

They should, however, understand what their agreement requires and whether the result still appears reasonable.

If nobody has run the numbers in years, that is worth knowing before someone has to.

Is There Actually Money to Fund the Purchase?

An agreement can create an obligation for the company, one or more owners, or another party to purchase an ownership interest.

That does not mean the money will automatically be available.

Some buy-sell arrangements rely on life insurance. Others contemplate company cash, owner funds, financing, installment payments, or some combination of sources.

Those assumptions can age just like the agreement itself.

Insurance purchased years ago may no longer correspond to the value of the interest. The company’s debt or cash position may have changed. A payment schedule that looked manageable when the agreement was signed may now place substantial pressure on the business.

This is one of the areas where legal counsel may need to work alongside financial, tax, insurance, and other advisers.

The documents and the funding plan should tell the same story.

Do the Trigger Events Still Fit the Ownership Relationship?

Death is the obvious event people associate with a buy-sell agreement.

But agreements may address considerably more: disability, retirement, termination of employment, bankruptcy, divorce, attempted transfers, deadlock, or an owner’s desire to leave.

Exactly which events matter, and what consequences follow, depend on the agreement and governing law.

Those provisions still need to fit the way the company operates now.

Suppose the agreement was drafted when every owner worked full time in the business. Years later, one owner is passive. Another is approaching retirement. A third has become central to day-to-day operations.

A provision tied to employment or retirement can mean something very different in that company than it did when everyone started.

The right time to discover that is before the trigger occurs.

What Happens If Everyone Is No Longer Getting Along?

Buy-sell agreements are usually negotiated when relationships are good.

That is precisely when the difficult questions are easiest to address.

  • What happens if one owner wants out?
  • What if the other owners do not want—or cannot afford—to buy?
  • What if everyone disagrees about value?
  • What if an owner wants to sell to someone outside the company?
  • What happens during a serious deadlock?

An agreement cannot eliminate every dispute. Nor should it try to anticipate every conceivable scenario.

But it should provide a workable process for the situations the owners can reasonably foresee.

An agreement that depends on everyone cooperating may be least useful at the moment it is needed most.

Does It Match the Rest of the Company’s Legal Structure?

The buy-sell agreement is only one part of the company’s legal architecture.

Operating agreements, bylaws, shareholder agreements, ownership records, insurance arrangements, financing documents, employment arrangements, and estate plans may all affect an ownership transition.

Those pieces do not always evolve together.

A transfer restriction in one document may not line up neatly with another. Insurance intended to fund a purchase may no longer match the obligation. An estate plan may assume an outcome the governing documents do not produce.

Often these are not dramatic problems.

They are simply inconsistencies that become much harder to deal with during a death, dispute, retirement, financing, or sale.

A periodic review gives the owners an opportunity to find them while there is still time to make deliberate decisions.

Will the Agreement Help—or Hinder—the Company’s Next Stage?

The company may not be facing a crisis at all.

It may be growing.

Perhaps the owners want to bring in another executive. Transition ownership to the next generation. Raise capital. Acquire another company. Prepare for an eventual sale.

Those plans can change what the owners need from their buy-sell arrangement.

An agreement designed for two founders may not work particularly well once there are five owners. Transfer restrictions that once provided useful protection may become cumbersome when the company begins considering investment or a sale.

That does not mean the agreement needs constant revision.

It means significant changes in the business are sensible moments to ask whether the ownership structure still supports where the company is going.

The Goal Is Not to Rewrite a Perfectly Good Agreement

A review should not begin with the assumption that something must be wrong.

Sometimes the answer is that the agreement still works.

That is useful information.

Other times, a focused review identifies one or two provisions that deserve attention. And sometimes the agreement exposes a broader issue involving governance, ownership, succession, financing, or future transactions.

The appropriate response should match the problem.

For some businesses, that may mean a discrete buy-sell review or revision project. For a company that is unsure where this issue sits among several legal priorities, a broader business legal review may make sense. And where ownership and governance questions are part of recurring legal needs, they may be better handled within an outside general counsel relationship.

The objective is not more legal work.

It is having an ownership arrangement that still works when the company needs it.

Lovstad Law advises business owners on buy-sell agreements, ownership transitions, governance, succession planning, business transactions, and ongoing outside general counsel needs. If your company has a buy-sell agreement that has not been reviewed as the business has changed, schedule an introductory call to discuss whether it still fits the company today.

Schedule an Introductory Call

This article provides general information and does not constitute legal, tax, financial, or insurance advice. The appropriate structure and review of a buy-sell agreement depend on the entity, governing documents, ownership structure, funding arrangements, applicable law, and particular circumstances.

More Related Insights & Articles
Schedule a Strategy Call